TRAVEL GEAR · HEAD TO HEAD

Hard-shell or soft-shell luggage for flying: which should you buy?

It's less about which is better and more about how you pack, where you go and what the airline's sizer will say.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Jump to the products mentioned ↓

Choose hard-shell if you want the best protection for what's inside and you pack to a fixed size; choose soft-side if you want outside pockets, a bit of give and a lighter bag. For checked bags, either works as long as it's under the airline's size and 23 kg limit. For carry-ons, size matters more than shell: very few bags of either kind fit both Air Canada and WestJet, so check the numbers before you buy.

An airport baggage claim hall with conveyor belts
Photo: Alexander Schimmeck on Unsplash

What hard-shell is good at

The trade-offs: it doesn't give, so a bag you've overpacked won't squeeze into a sizer; there are usually no outside pockets; and scratches show. Example: the Samsonite Freeform Spinner Carry-On in its 21.5-inch Canadian model measures 54.6 × 36.8 × 22.9 cm with wheels and weighs 2.6 kg.

Clothes and shoes packed in an open suitcase
Two medium bags are easier to keep under 23 kg than one huge one. Photo: Arnel Hasanovic on Unsplash

What soft-side is good at

The trade-offs: fabric absorbs moisture and stains, fragile items need their own padding, and an expandable bag that's zipped open can be too deep for a carry-on sizer. Example: the Travelpro Maxlite 5 International Carry-On measures 55.2 × 40.1 × 19.6 cm with wheels and weighs 2.4 kg. That's 0.2 kg lighter than the Samsonite above, but it is a couple of millimetres over Air Canada's length and width limits, so a strict agent could flag it, and at 40.1 cm wide it is too wide for WestJet's 36 cm.

For a carry-on: size beats shell

The size that fits both Air Canada and WestJet is 55 × 36 × 23 cm or smaller. A shell type doesn't change that. If you fly WestJet, the width is the number to watch, and a hard shell is less forgiving at the limit; if you fly Air Canada, the 23 cm depth is the one that catches soft bags once their pockets are full. Our carry-on luggage guide lists bags by airline, and our baggage limits table has every airline's limits.

For a checked bag: protection and weight

Checked bags have a size limit (about 158 cm in total on Air Canada and 157 cm on WestJet, adding height, width and depth) and a usual limit of 23 kg. A medium hard-shell such as the Samsonite Freeform Medium Spinner is about 71 × 50 × 34 cm, around 155 cm in total, and 3.85 kg empty, so it's under both size limits but uses 3.85 of your 23 kg before you pack. A lighter soft-side bag leaves more room for what you bring. Either way, weigh the bag before you leave home.

Our call

Hard-shell for checked bags that carry fragile or valuable things, for rainy places and for people who pack to the size. Soft-side for carry-ons you pack tightly, for pockets, and for anyone counting every 100 g. If you can't decide, choose by airline: the sizer at the gate matters more than the fabric.

Our checked luggage guide: sizes and the bags we pick →

The short version

Side by side

Hard-shellSoft-side
Protects fragile itemsBetterNeeds padding
Rain and spillsSheds waterFabric absorbs
Outside pocketsUsually noneOften several
Fits when overpackedNo, it won't giveA little give
Weight (the two models above)2.6 kg carry-on2.4 kg carry-on
Shows scratches and stainsScratchesStains and wear
Best forChecked bags, fragile items, rainTightly packed carry-ons, pockets

The two weights are for the Samsonite and Travelpro models named above; weight varies by model.

In this article

Products mentioned in this article

Everything linked above, in one place. Named products open that product on Amazon.ca; the others open an Amazon.ca search, so you can compare brands and today's prices.

Hard-shell carry-on for Air Canada

Samsonite Freeform Spinner Carry-On

Specs54.6 × 36.8 × 22.9 cm with wheels, 2.6 kg (Samsonite Canada)

Fits Air Canada. 0.8 cm too wide for WestJet. Get the 21.5-inch Canadian model: the newer 10-inch-deep version is bigger.

Why we picked it
  • The 21.5-inch Canadian model
  • 0.8 cm too wide for WestJet
  • Rigid shell, spinner wheels
Check price on Amazon.ca
Hard-shell checked bag

Samsonite Freeform Medium Spinner

Look forAbout 71 × 50 × 34 cm (about 155 cm in total), 3.85 kg empty

Why we picked it
  • Under Air Canada's 158 cm and WestJet's 157 cm limits
  • Protects fragile items
  • Sources differ on the exact centimetres
Check price on Amazon.ca
Soft-side carry-on

Travelpro Maxlite 5 International Carry-On Spinner

Specs55.2 × 40.1 × 19.6 cm with wheels, 2.4 kg (Travelpro Canada)

2 mm over Air Canada's length and width, so a strict agent could flag it. Too wide for WestJet.

Why we picked it
  • Lighter, with room for pockets
  • A couple of mm over Air Canada's size, too wide for WestJet
  • Expandable: keep it zipped for the sizer
Find it on Amazon.ca

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Fly for less

Trips where your bag gets tested

Travel gear

More gear guides

All gear guides

Get flight deals from your city by email

One short email a week, only when we find a real deal from your city. Every fare is re-checked live before we send it. Free, and you can unsubscribe any time.

We only email you fare alerts, plus tips and offers if you tick the box. How our alerts work · Privacy policy
Questions

Common questions

Is hard-shell or soft-shell luggage better for flying?

Hard-shell protects what's inside better and sheds water, which suits checked bags. Soft-side has outside pockets and a little give, which suits carry-ons you pack tightly. Size and weight limits matter more than the shell.

Which type is lighter?

It depends on the model. Of the two we compare, the soft-side Travelpro carry-on is 0.2 kg lighter than the hard-shell Samsonite, but many lightweight hard-shells exist. Check the empty weight of the bag you're buying.

Can a soft-shell carry-on be squeezed into the sizer?

A little. Fabric gives slightly where a rigid shell doesn't, but an expandable bag zipped open can be too deep, so keep it zipped for the gate.

What size checked bag is allowed on Air Canada and WestJet?

Up to about 158 cm in total on Air Canada and 157 cm on WestJet (height plus width plus depth), and usually 23 kg on economy fares. Check your own fare, as basic fares may include no checked bag.

Sources

Checked October 31, 2026. Airline rules change, so check with your airline before you fly.